Moore Haven. Photo by Glades County News

The proposed property tax cut on Florida’s November ballot could save homeowners money but potentially increase costs for renters, according to a new housing analysis released this week.

Amendment 3 would sharply increase Florida’s homestead property tax exemption for taxes collected by counties and cities, a new analysis highlighted by the Florida Housing Coalition shows. The exemption would rise from $50,000 today to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028. School property taxes would not be affected.

The analysis estimates that non-school property tax collections across Florida could fall by about 20% to 23%, or roughly $8.7 billion a year by 2029. That loss could grow to nearly $11.8 billion annually by 2032.

Local governments would have several options to deal with the loss: cut spending, raise property tax rates on properties that remain taxable, or increase other taxes and fees.

The new study looked specifically at what could happen if local governments tried to replace all of the lost revenue by raising property tax rates.

Under that scenario, the average property tax bill on a Florida apartment could increase by about $406 a year in 2028 and $554 by 2031. For single-family rental homes, the estimated increase is much larger — about $1,081 in 2028 and $1,471 by 2031.

The report says landlords generally pass much of property tax increases on to tenants over time. It cited research suggesting renters can eventually absorb at least 60% of those costs through higher rents.

That could matter in Glades County, where about 15% of occupied homes are rentals. The median gross rent in Glades County is currently $886 per month, according to the latest U.S. Census Bureau figures. The county’s owner-occupied housing rate is 85.1%.

Glades County already warning about lost revenue

The new report adds another issue to a property tax debate that has already drawn concern from Glades County officials.

County Manager Paul Carlisle has warned that Amendment 3 could cost Glades County approximately $2.5 million each year in property tax revenue. Unlike larger and faster-growing counties, Glades relies heavily on property taxes and has a relatively small tax base. Carlisle said such a large loss could force county commissioners to make difficult decisions about services including road paving, pothole repairs, animal control, code enforcement, planning and zoning, and building services.

The Glades County Sheriff’s Office has also warned that losing property tax revenue could put pressure on its already tight budget.

The report also warns that higher taxes and uncertainty over how counties respond could make it more difficult to build new apartments and affordable housing. Developers and lenders could face uncertainty over future tax rates, fees and local government services, potentially delaying or reducing some projects.

Poll shows Amendment 3 below 60% needed to pass

The report comes as a new statewide poll shows Amendment 3 well below the support required for approval.

A St. Pete Polls survey of 913 likely Florida voters, conducted September 15-17, found 44.9% supported Amendment 3, while 30.4% opposed it and 24.8% were undecided. The survey had a margin of error of 3.2 percentage points.

Florida constitutional amendments need at least 60% of the statewide vote to pass.

The poll also showed a large partisan difference. Nearly 63% of Republicans supported the amendment, compared with about 24% of Democrats and 40% of independent voters.

An earlier University of North Florida poll also showed how concerns about the financial impact could affect public support. In that survey, 61% initially supported the proposal, but support fell to 45% after voters were told about the possible loss of revenue to counties and cities.

Nate Maize's avatar

By Nate Maize

Nate Maize is the senior writer for Glades County News, covering local government, development and community life across Glades County.

Leave a Reply